Gene Rodenberry’s vision of future humanity changed history and has inspired millions across the globe and over generations to look to the stars for hope. Star Trek showed us a version of ourselves to which we could aspire – one of an egalitarian meritocratic utopia of humans free from suffering and want. The problems were no longer within us, they were all out there, in that great big universe. That was also where all the possibilities were to be found.
What underlay that onscreen society was not simply human social enlightenment but a core set of technical capabilities that had eliminated the fundamental driver of conflict throughout human history: scarcity of resources.
The limitations on peace between people have historically been directly related to the limitations on people’s ability to achieve food, shelter, and physical security – the bottom rungs of Maslow’s heirarchy of needs. The inability to satisfy those basic requirements, due to a scarcity of resources has parasitically sapped effort from advances in health, art, and social well-being, not to mention non-violent technologies of all kinds.
Hegel, Marx and their derivatives, saw this as a cause for revolution resulting in a socialist or communist state as the solution. History has proven them to be wrong, but capitalism, while preferable is not perfect. Regardless of the method, the point of these systems is to create a structure for access to resources upon which society can agree. What Star Trek showed us was a universe so full of resources just ready and available for the taking that it made more sense for humanity to work together to develop the technology to acquire those resources and revel in the abundance than to engage in conflict for resources on Earth.
It showed us a future of humanity in which scarcity of resources had been eliminated and thus the greatest driver of conflict in our civilization no longer existed. Now, in 2023, humanity is poised to take its first steps towards eliminating scarcity. Many factors are driving this but foremost is technology, not just in space but also artificial intelligence, the availability of data and storage, computational speed, and key advances in materials. The environment is another factor. We need to learn to be productive off this world in order to save it. The opportunity to leverage the space environment is also a key factor that will affect many human endeavours. Finally, the education and awareness of people around the world, which was previously considered a happy by product, has become a driver for us to go beyond, as people and nations of all sizes and technological sophistication look to capture space benefits for themselves. As is typical of human endeavours the path and process has so far been messy, although led by the most powerful and resourced groups.
What some see emerging is yet another tragedy of the commons, in space instead of on Earth. However, such thinking is ultimately small minded. Even as nations such as Luxembourg and Canada rush to create structures for ownership of space resources and China attempts to create their own monopoly in space, other companies and national agencies are attempting to create a paradigm of open access. We must hope that the latter win out in a way that still promotes private enterprise to go and capture resources.
An asteroid such as Psyche, to which NASA will send a probe, launching later this year, could completely disrupt and flatten the nickel and cobalt commodity markets if the ore there could be captured. Other asteroids of which there are tens to hundreds of thousands are each worth trillions of dollars by today’s market prices but would effectively eliminate the scarcity of critical metals that exists today on earth.
Closer still, the moon is rich with so called rare-Earth metals deposited there by asteroid impacts. Furthermore, through the capture of these resources we would eliminate horrific mining operations around the world – a major benefit both to the environment and to the people working in near slave conditions to extract resources such as cobalt from mines in Africa.